Kindness is not always the first quality that comes to mind when one imagines the director of a large national museum. Yet anyone I talk to who knows Lonnie Bunch, even tangentially, is unable to restrain themselves from complimenting both his kindness and his industry. He describes his work slightly differently, as ‘a career of service using history and culture as a way to help people understand themselves and as a way to bring people together’. It is a noble intention and one that has guided his 43-year career, much of which was devoted to the Smithsonian Institution until he announced his resignation as secretary earlier this year.
While Bunch has led the Smithsonian since 2019, one of his greatest achievements was the opening of the National Museum of African American History and Culture in 2016. Its arrival was a long time coming. As Bunch says, ‘people [had] wanted to do this since 1915’. It was the work of Congressman John Lewis who made it possible. Lewis spent 17 years repeatedly introducing legislation to Congress to allow the museum to be built. After much effort, the legislation was passed. Bunch entered the process feeling ‘a real pressure to fulfil the dreams of many’. While he was telling staff, ‘we’re doing what people don’t think you can do, so let’s really kick ass and do that’, he was also taking the time to put together what is one of the greatest achievements of the Smithsonian in recent years.
Bunch founded the museum with a passionate belief that ‘we are not building a museum about a particular culture for a particular culture. What we are doing is saying that this is both a people’s story [and] it’s a nation’s journey.’ The result is a museum that is among the most diversely visited in the world: 45 per cent of its visitors are not African American. He was able to achieve this, in part, by declaring the museum open before the building had even been begun. This 11-year headstart meant that he could hire the best candidates from the outset, giving him time to ‘not only dream but conceive’ of what the museum should be. It also allowed him time to raise the money (‘my mother said “more than God can count”’) so that no corners were cut.
Not every curator takes such a long-term view of their institution. But Bunch is not a traditional curator; he is a historian. ‘I brought a historian’s eye, but I also brought a curatorial interest in collections and exhibits and things that traditional historians don’t,’ he says. It is this range that led him to curate the career-defining exhibition ‘Black Olympians’ in 1984, timed to coincide with the Los Angeles Olympic Games. It allowed him to present local histories; the stories of individual athletes through their university and school years. It created a picture of different communities, but it also illustrated a larger theme: ‘The idea was that sport is more than “see how fast they ran”. It is really a tool for social justice. It’s a tool to find fairness.’
Bunch’s most recent exhibition, ‘American Aspirations’, which closed in August this year, addressed questions of social justice even more directly. It is unavoidable for an exhibition celebrating the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States to do so, but it came at a particularly difficult time for the museum. Bunch describes it as ‘probably the most dangerous time for the Smithsonian since the Civil War’. The Trump administration has pursued the Smithsonian for allegedly being un-American. ‘During our Nation’s 250th Anniversary Year, the Museum has failed to give George Washington and our other Founding Fathers the celebration they deserve,’ the president declared. Yet ‘American Aspirations’ opened and closed with images of Thomas Jefferson, in a conscious decision by Bunch to ensure the Founding Fathers were at the centre of what the Smithsonian showed for the semiquincentennial.
‘For me,’ Bunch says, ‘Jefferson helped us realise that America is both a place and an ideal, a place and a set of aspirations. [The exhibition] was able to say that it is these aspirations that have shaped the country, and that America is a work in progress, and that in essence, there’s nothing wrong with pushing a country to live up to its goals, to live up to being a more perfect union, to [have] high expectations.’
If this sounds dangerously close to idealism in an imperfect world, the pressures faced by the museum have made Bunch more idealistic rather than less. ‘My belief is that I need to make sure that, whoever follows me, people recognise that there are certain red lines you have to defend: independence, academic integrity,’ he says. These are ideals that the Trump administration, with its Senate committee hearings and diatribes, has sought specifically to undermine. Bunch does not claim perfection, but he has sought to protect the institution. ‘As a former curator,’ he says, ‘I know there have been times I’ve overreached. But that means that the institution should make those mid-course corrections that no one else should.’ To navigate the conception and construction of a new museum on the National Mall, to lead an organisation and to have the diplomatic ability to defend and protect one of the country’s greatest institutions from external interference is quite the career. It could even be described as heroic.
Edward Behrens, editor of Apollo.